Competition Shortlist F to J : The Judges’ Views

Here is the third instalment of the judges’ views on the listed poems which were performed in the Elwin Room on Saturday 26th September 2015.

Annie Fisher : The Innocents

The judges said: We liked the restrained approach to good and evil in The Innocents.  This opened avenues of thought and imagination without dictating what the listeners’ conclusions ought to be.   A poem of apparent simplicity, rich in possibilities.

Louise Green : Sieste with Jean Gabriel

This poem comes from a sequence about real and imagined lives in rural France in the last century. The sonnet, with its ‘turn’, seemed right for this rather unusual subject. The Cafe judges said: ‘Sieste’ is an artful, seductive, challenging poem, full of surprises and shocks.  We liked the way the bucolic jostles the gothic and also the way that the unexpected ending forces you to reread, hunting for the clues which this skilful writer might have left half-hidden in the lines. 

Caroline Heaton : Guinevere’s Gown

The judges said: The words are beautifully chosen. The poem’s incantatory quality and formal mastery create an entirely convincing and enticing universe.

Rosie Jackson : John Donne Arriving  in Heaven

This is a composite of various sources: the title comes from a painting by Stanley Spencer, some of the ideas are from Donne’s poems and sermons, while the final section is filtered through my own spiritual beliefs, prominent because I wrote this while on retreat in India. The Cafe judges said: We liked the way the poet’s command of both subject matter and language are crafted together to make a poem that is dazzlingly new. 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s